Vue Software

Tag Archive for 'MBO'

Management by Objectives

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (7 votes, average: 3.29 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

I’ve talked about MBOs – Management by Objectives – a few times before, but I will dedicate a few posts to this topic. As a quick reminder, MBOs is a process where measurable objectives are set, and the employee performance is then measured against those objectives. The goal is to increase the workforce’s performance and engagement through proper motivation. MBOs are particularly important because they are not only for organizations with a sales force; any employee can be incented with this strategy, and as such, most type of organizations use them in one way or another.

The other reason I want to talk about MBOs is that software vendors are slowly broadening their offerings.  Instead of having one IT solution to align objectives to corporate goals, one workflow solution to calculate incentives against these goals, one solution to manage sales compensation, etc, single vendors are starting to cover the entire spectrum with a single variable pay solution. That’s what is called “pervasive performance management”.  Software providers in the sales performance space are starting to offer MBO functionality, and MBO software providers are starting to offer sales compensation modules.

So how do MBOs typically work? There are a lot of resources out there on this topic. Typically, the employee is asked to define SMART objectives; objectives that are Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Realistic, and Time-related. These objectives should reflect the organizational goals and be specific to each employee. The reason for using the SMART approach is that we need to be able to verify if the objectives were achieved later.

After some interaction with a manager, the objectives should be approved by both the employee and manager. At the end of the performance cycle, the objectives will be reviewed, and the manager will then decide to which extent each employee has achieved their personal objectives.

The system is not perfect and there are many challenges. How do you make sure the employees define objectives that are “hard enough” to reach? How do you evaluate an employee if an objective is missed for reasons out of his or her control? I will come back to this and share some ideas later.

For now I’ll discuss another major challenge: How do you manage all the workflow of approvals required to incent the employees based on their performance?

Traditionally, this is done using spreadsheets. The employee e-mails a spreadsheet to their manager. The manager reviews and e-mail it back to the employee. The employee makes some changes and e-mail it back to the manager. The manager is satisfied and e-mails the spreadsheet to a senior manager. The senior manager approves the objectives and e-mails back the approved spreadsheet to the manager. At the end of the year, the same process takes place again to distribute performance bonuses to each employee. That’s a lot of e-mails going back and forth, and many companies are struggling to centralize all this objective and performance information. And that’s not mentioning the difficulties to track the trends in the employees’ performance, perform other analysis by strategic objective, by department, etc, and to record information for audit purposes. These are all good examples of why having a solid MBO solution to facilitate this workflow is important.

In the following weeks, I will review many leading MBO solutions and demonstrate the benefits of using them instead of using spreadsheets.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Related Posts:
A review of Callidus Software’s New MBO Solution: TrueMBO
Webinar: Demystifying the Complexity of Sales Performance Management – Business vs Technology

Excentive Incentive Management Review

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (15 votes, average: 3.73 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

Here is my latest Incentive Compensation Management application review. This week I am reviewing a relatively unknown (in North America) solution called Excentive Incentive Management.  Excentive was incorporated in 2002. Since then, they have gained a lot of popularity in France and have signed major clients such as Canon, Orange, and Air France. Earlier this year, they raised 700,000 Euros ($880,000 US) to accelerate international growth, part of over $1 million raised in recent months to fuel global expansion.

They also assembled an additional team driven by 10 seasoned managers active in the globalization of companies such as SAP, Hyperion, and OutlookSoft. One of their key target markets is of course North America, so we may soon start seeing some Excentive implementations over here if they can overcome some major challenges ahead, namely convincing prospective clients that they have the capability to deliver and support their implementations in the US, and that they are financially stable.

What is particularly interesting about the Excentive solution is that it includes performance management modules in addition to the sales performance solution. It makes it easy to compensate employees based on MBO campaigns. It’s a very flexible solution which can be a good option for as few as 50 payees, to as many as 50,000 payees, and it can be deployed on-premise or hosted.  Excentive Incentive Management is deployed across industries, and some implementations can process as many as 2 million transactions daily.

From the “regular” employee perspective, the application mostly consists of a repository of reports. These reports can be configured and customized by an administrator, but standard reports exist for most common information such as commission statements and performance review results.

Employees can also see the details of their compensation plans and can easily find out which commission was paid and find out if any transactions are missing.

Managers have access to additional information such as their team’s performance, salaries, etc.

Managers can also consult their employee’s records containing information about their past performance such as commissions earned in previous periods.

In addition to reports, managers can edit some of their team’s information including new salary figures, bonus values, based on constraints configured by the administrators.

One of the biggest features for managers is to be able to provide rating for their employees’ performance and to reuse all that info in a salary review process or a stock option allocation exercise, which are also supported by Excentive.

Finally, let’s look at some of the configuration of the solution, from the administrator’s perspective.
“Campaigns”, or the performance management component, can be configured in a few clicks from the campaigns menu.

Bonus and commission rules can be configured easily in a 3-step process. First, the properties of the rule are setup which includes the name of the rule and the dates for which it is effective. The rules engine can thus access the quantitative data (eg. sales by product/territory/period , margins, etc) as well as the quantitative performance indicators (eg. team spirit, customer loyalty, etc). This allows the calculation of the incentive (commission) as well as the bonus. Rules can be used for the classic earnings calculations as well as for recommendations and simulations.

The criteria step consists of specifying the conditions which must be met for the commission to fire.
This formula can be typed in, or created by clicking on the functions and other information stored in the database.

The resulting calculation is configured in the same way as the condition.

The reports we have looked at so far were all numbers presented in a tabular format, but it’s also possible to integrate visual elements to dashboards and reports.

Excentive’s solution also includes integrated modules to perform more complex tasks:

  • Hierarchy Manager: combine different dimensions such as region/office/people into multiple hierarchies necessary for workflow and approval processes.
  • Pool Manager: create teams and delegate ‘people-to-team’ assignments to local managers.
  • Mobility Manager: spot team changes and transfer people between departments/managers. Manage partial, time and team depending compensations
  • Culture Manager associate people with language, currency, location
  • Environment Manager which is a secure and fast way to move an application change from a development environment towards a test or production environment

Overall, Excentive is a slick web based application which shows a lot of promise if they can inspire enough trust from prospective clients. Since all modules are integrated in one solution at no additional cost, Excentive could be a good play for clients looking for not only incentive compensation management, but the entire spectrum of salary and performance management. Now could be a good time to negotiate a favorable price from the vendor, given that they are aggressively trying to enter this North American market.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Related Posts:
Excentive
Merced Systems