Incentive Compensation and Sales Performance Management Survey

Tag Archive for 'Review'

ActekSoft ACom3 Review

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (4 votes, average: 3.75 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

ActekSoft was founded in 1999 and currently supports over 30 clients (mostly in the insurance industry).  I talked about them earlier this year when they got acquired by Callidus Software. Acteksoft’s flagship product is called ACom3 and can be deployed On-Premise or On-Demand.  Approximately one third of ActekSoft’s clients are currently hosted.

As I’ve discussed in a previous post, Gartner recently released their 2009 ICM MarketScope for the insurance industry. Gartner cites the following as some of the main reasons why ActekSoft deserved a positive rating:

ActekSoft was rated Positive this year, due primarily to its deep understanding and ability to deliver health insurance requirements, the number of new deals in the past 12 months and the positive nature of its customer references. Four of its customers were interviewed for this report… Several themes resonated throughout these interviews. First, ActekSoft is very committed to the pricing that is quoted to the customer… Second, customers cite a culture of customer satisfaction and commitment to project delivery.

ACom3 is accessible via a web browser. After logging into the application, administrators find themselves into a relatively intuitive interface; the various application areas are accessed via the top menu, and configuration for each of those areas are accessible in the left menu. Different sections can also be expanded and collapsed by clicking on the + or - icons. The content of each of these sections is completely configurable by simply dragging and dropping fields into the appropriate section. Sections can also easily be added as required.

A plan consists of ‘schedules’ which are applicable to a certain region and hierarchy. These schedules are rule driven and reference formulas, filters, tables, etc. Reference data is typically imported into the application, but editing information such as transaction details or producer information can be performed manually by inserting text into text boxes, or by selecting values from drop down menus.

The look and feel of the interface for payees is very similar to the administrator’s interface. Upon logging in the application, the payees can access performance details for themselves and for their subordinates via reports and dashboards. They can also access important information such as their appointments, their book of business, etc.

All of these features are very similar to what is expected from any sales performance management solution, so you may wonder what makes ACom3 different than other non-insurance specific solutions. I will discuss some of these differentiators in my next post.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Related Posts:
Callidus Software Acquires ActekSoft
ActekSoft ACom3 Review Part 2

Varicent SPM 6.0 and Presenter Review

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (8 votes, average: 3.13 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

Varicent announced a new major release of their application – Varicent SPM 6.0 – at their user conference on Monday. The new features of this release include a new module called Presenter (a tool to build interactive sales reports), Model Manager (a tool to facilitate the management of multiple compensation models / lines of business), and CRM Integration (providing the ability to embed Varicent SPM into Microsoft Dynamics CRM). I spent the past 3 days training on this new release of Varicent SPM, and in particular on the Presenter module which I will review now.

Presenter allows to create and configure custom reports, and to publish them to the web. In the past, Varicent users had to use the “Web Forms” module to create similar reports, but web forms are more complex to build, and lack key features such as the ability to embed graphs. This new module is supposed to empower business users to design their own reports, directly from within the Varicent SPM application.

Reports consist of 4 key components storing data:
- Calculations
- Parameters (restrictions on the results being displayed)
- Scalars (variable returning single value)
- Sources (where the information is coming from)

As well as other building blocks: Images, Text, Controls, Scalars, Fixed Grid, Data Grids and Charts. Creating a report only consists of adding these elements to the empty report page.

The positioning of the objects on the report is fairly straightforward and consists of creating tables and inserting the objects in their own cell. In order to position everything perfectly, tables can be embedded into each other (a new table created within the cell of another table), etc. The positioning of the objects can be fine tuned by adjusting the cell’s alignment settings, borders and cell spacing. In other words, positioning objects in Presenter’s reports feels exactly like designing a web page a few years ago before CSS became a standard.

Presenter also includes many other formatting features which should be familiar from Excel. For example, borders and cell shading can be adjusted in a very similar way, and it is even easy to setup some conditional formatting (such as a cell being highlighted in yellow if a commission is over a certain amount). Reports can also include links to other reports which allows to “drill down” on specific results. Presenter reports can be made very “dynamic” by including dropdown menus (called pick lists by Varicent) to filter results for certain people, product lines, etc.

Once the objects are inserted into the report, clicking on the “Preview” tab shows how the report would look like on the web once it is published, using actual calculation results.

So can “business users” really create their own reports? Presenter seems to be much easier to use than other BI/reporting applications such as Actuate and Business Objects and does not require any reporting experience. Furthermore, simple reports can be created fairly rapidly. This being said, the ‘complexity’ lies in figuring out which sources or calculations need to be used, and also to be able to create these objects when required. For someone with Varicent implementation experience, the learning curve should be very quick.

Tags: , , , , , ,

Related Posts:
Varicent
Varicent Insight 2009

A review of Callidus Software’s New MBO Solution: TrueMBO

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (9 votes, average: 3.78 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

Before I left on vacation, I wrote a few posts on Management by Objectives (MBO), but I didn’t have time to post the solution reviews before leaving. I will now resume this series by posting a quick review of one of Callidus Software’s latest on-demand offering called TrueMBO.

As I mentioned in the previous posts, administering the MBO process can be very time consuming. TrueMBO eliminates the need for back and forth e-mails between employees and managers when objectives are being decided upon, and also later when employees are assigned a performance achievement for each objective. It can also be used as a central point to administer MBOs company-wide.

When a manager logs in TrueMBO, he or she will see 3 sections; one section displays the MBO programs currently setup, another is the Inbox section where managers and employees can exchange messages related to MBOs, and the last section is for the many pre-configured and customized reports.

Clicking on the name of the MBO Program opens up a new tab with additional information and options. In this tab, a manager will be able to set objectives for the program, to score these objectives, and to notify the team of their performance. The Organization Hierarchy panel shows the manager’s subordinates. Finally, the Team Status provides the most useful information to the manager by illustrating the MBO phase in which each team member is.

Setting up objectives is also a very intuitive task, where objectives are being given a name and a weight (which must total 100%), and a target payout (how much money is earned if the objective is met). These objectives can also be picked from previously used objectives, or from a library which can be defined by an administrator.

The employee’s interface is even simpler than the manager’s, and provides the employee with the ability to exchange messages with his or her manager, to participate to setting up and accepting their objectives, to approve the ‘scores’ and associated bonus received, and to view various reports related to their performance.

If you are looking for a simple on-demand solution to administer your performance evaluation process, TrueMBO could be the right solution for you. TrueMBO will appeal in particular to companies already using Callidus Software’s solutions because of the possible synergies with the Callidus Sales Performance on-demand applications (hierarchy maintenance, performance calculations, etc), but it can also be used as a standalone MBO solution. TrueMBO is available for 5$ per employee per month until the end of June 2009.

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Related Posts:
A small sovereign city-state located in South Western Europe on the northern central coast of the Mediterranean Sea
Callidus Software

Excentive Incentive Management Review

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (15 votes, average: 3.73 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

Here is my latest Incentive Compensation Management application review. This week I am reviewing a relatively unknown (in North America) solution called Excentive Incentive Management.  Excentive was incorporated in 2002. Since then, they have gained a lot of popularity in France and have signed major clients such as Canon, Orange, and Air France. Earlier this year, they raised 700,000 Euros ($880,000 US) to accelerate international growth, part of over $1 million raised in recent months to fuel global expansion.

They also assembled an additional team driven by 10 seasoned managers active in the globalization of companies such as SAP, Hyperion, and OutlookSoft. One of their key target markets is of course North America, so we may soon start seeing some Excentive implementations over here if they can overcome some major challenges ahead, namely convincing prospective clients that they have the capability to deliver and support their implementations in the US, and that they are financially stable.

What is particularly interesting about the Excentive solution is that it includes performance management modules in addition to the sales performance solution. It makes it easy to compensate employees based on MBO campaigns. It’s a very flexible solution which can be a good option for as few as 50 payees, to as many as 50,000 payees, and it can be deployed on-premise or hosted.  Excentive Incentive Management is deployed across industries, and some implementations can process as many as 2 million transactions daily.

From the “regular” employee perspective, the application mostly consists of a repository of reports. These reports can be configured and customized by an administrator, but standard reports exist for most common information such as commission statements and performance review results.

Employees can also see the details of their compensation plans and can easily find out which commission was paid and find out if any transactions are missing.

Managers have access to additional information such as their team’s performance, salaries, etc.

Managers can also consult their employee’s records containing information about their past performance such as commissions earned in previous periods.

In addition to reports, managers can edit some of their team’s information including new salary figures, bonus values, based on constraints configured by the administrators.

One of the biggest features for managers is to be able to provide rating for their employees’ performance and to reuse all that info in a salary review process or a stock option allocation exercise, which are also supported by Excentive.

Finally, let’s look at some of the configuration of the solution, from the administrator’s perspective.
“Campaigns”, or the performance management component, can be configured in a few clicks from the campaigns menu.

Bonus and commission rules can be configured easily in a 3-step process. First, the properties of the rule are setup which includes the name of the rule and the dates for which it is effective. The rules engine can thus access the quantitative data (eg. sales by product/territory/period , margins, etc) as well as the quantitative performance indicators (eg. team spirit, customer loyalty, etc). This allows the calculation of the incentive (commission) as well as the bonus. Rules can be used for the classic earnings calculations as well as for recommendations and simulations.

The criteria step consists of specifying the conditions which must be met for the commission to fire.
This formula can be typed in, or created by clicking on the functions and other information stored in the database.

The resulting calculation is configured in the same way as the condition.

The reports we have looked at so far were all numbers presented in a tabular format, but it’s also possible to integrate visual elements to dashboards and reports.

Excentive’s solution also includes integrated modules to perform more complex tasks:

  • Hierarchy Manager: combine different dimensions such as region/office/people into multiple hierarchies necessary for workflow and approval processes.
  • Pool Manager: create teams and delegate ‘people-to-team’ assignments to local managers.
  • Mobility Manager: spot team changes and transfer people between departments/managers. Manage partial, time and team depending compensations
  • Culture Manager associate people with language, currency, location
  • Environment Manager which is a secure and fast way to move an application change from a development environment towards a test or production environment

Overall, Excentive is a slick web based application which shows a lot of promise if they can inspire enough trust from prospective clients. Since all modules are integrated in one solution at no additional cost, Excentive could be a good play for clients looking for not only incentive compensation management, but the entire spectrum of salary and performance management. Now could be a good time to negotiate a favorable price from the vendor, given that they are aggressively trying to enter this North American market.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Related Posts:
Excentive
Merced Systems

Makana Motivator Pro Review

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (6 votes, average: 4 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

Last November, I briefly talked about the newly released Makana Motivator Pro. Motivator Pro is an on-demand Sales Performance Management application which like Motivator Express helps with the design of compensation plans, but which also offers new payment and reporting modules. Unlike most SPM solutions, Motivator Pro is a self-serve solution (no additional implementation costs) designed for companies with a sales force with less than 100 payees.

I reviewed the planning features of Motivator (now called Motivator Express) already, so I will focus on reviewing the features that are new with Motivator Pro in this post.

Once logged in the administration interface, it is easy to see at a glance how to get started. We see 4 items in the top menu; Home, Planning, Payment, and Setup. The dashboard consists of 3 options; Take the Tour, Launch Plan Wizard, and Join Your Peers.

Planning
Creating a new plan using the step-by-step wizard is simple and straightforward. First, you select a category of positions which Motivator calls a job role. This will be the title of the plan document.

Step number 2 consists of specifying the target pay at 100% and the base salary. As with Motivator Express, some planning tips are provided during the configuration. Similarly, goals are defined in step 3 and goal payments are defined in step 4.

The design of the plans is very similar to how planning was performed in Makana Motivator Express. A green star in their top left corner indicates if the plans are in “production”.

Building the organization and hierarchy is done through the “Build Your Org” tab. Payee information can be uploaded, or created via the user interface.

Cost modeling is also straightforward. Projected payout is based on a percentage of historical attainment. and attainment assumptions can be changed globally, at the participant level, and even for each goal for an individual Projections are automatically rolled up to show total sales and incentive costs.

Many useful graphs can show information such as the quota attainment distribution.



Payment

The “Your Plans” tab in the Payment section displays all the plans currently designed. Each of the plan sections can be expanded to display more information (Measures, Formulas, and Payouts). The dates for which a plan is effective is displayed at the bottom of the plan. Once the plans are designed and ready to be used, it’s time to visit the “Assign Credit” tab and to import the orders. This is done via a simple file upload and the credits are automatically assigned based on the rules created during the planning phase. With another click, you can calculate the incentive payments for those credit assignments

Once payments are calculated, reports are automatically generated. These reports can be downloaded in an Excel or PDF format.

A web portal will also be available by the end of January, where payees will login and view their personal performance, their team’s performance, their ranking, and detailed reports on a dashboard.

The “Pro” in Motivator is a great addition which will benefit existing and new Makana customers alike. The main question, I was hoping to answer as a result of the demo was, is that solution really simple and intuitive enough for self-service. I think I can safely answer that yes it is, but it will take a bit of practice if the administrator is new to the comp world. However, the wizard and the online help, as well as the detailed “tips” displayed throughout the configuration should make it very quick to learn. Priced at $29 per month per payee with no implementation fee, this could be the right solution to finally replace those inaccurate spreadsheets and ineffective compensation plans.

For more information, click here to take a quick tour.

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Related Posts:
Makana Solutions
“New” Sales Compensation Solution – Makana Motivator Pro

Merced Incentive Management (MIM) Review Part 2

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (4 votes, average: 4 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

During the demo we logged in the application as an administrator.  As you can see, the top menu gives access to major application ‘areas’, and the left menu shows information which is relevant to the active area.  When we navigated to the “payees” area, we see the “most recently used” payees, and the related areas.  Most areas also include a search tool to easily find what we are looking for.  Finally, as expected, the payees are listed, grouped by title (which Merced Incentive Management calls “roles”).


Merced Incentive Management supports multiple hierarchies, called “sales structures”.  The company hierarchy can be displayed in a graphical way, and “drilled down” as required.

This is when I noticed what I think is one of the best feature of Merced Incentive Management.  It uses a “tab” navigation system which we have grown accustomed to in our web browsers, making the navigation from screen to screen (and back) very easy and convenient.

Clicking on a payee opens another tab, displaying that payee’s information.

Some of the information can be modified by updating the values in the text boxes or drown down menus, but others require to pick a value from a list and other settings.  For example, changing a role required to specify the new roles with the effective dates for that role.  These changes make a window “pop-up” on the screen while fading the information in the background.  That was another very nice eye-candy I have not seen in other solutions.  This concept of “pop-ups” is used throughout the application.

Building a Plan

Plans in Merced Incentive Management, are not what other applications call a plan.  In every other application I have seen, a payee can only be part of ONE plan, and the plan consists of all the rules including commissions and bonuses for the payees assigned to the plan.

In Merced, a plan is an object which contains all the logic to come up with a set of results, multiple plans are assigned to each payee.  So for example, if we have 4 different bonuses for an individual, each of those bonuses is considered a plan.  The first time I talked with Merced about their application, they mentioned the application supported several thousands of plans for some clients.  I did not understand why a sane (or even an insane) client would want that many plans.  This explains it.

If it’s still not clear, I hope it will make sense after I explain how the plans perform calculations.

Back to the plan screen; the screen is divided in a few sections.  The “plan summary” section shows the plan name, the plan group, the target and the effective dates.  The plan filter section shows specifies the data source and every filter applied to that data. Finally, the bulk of the logic takes place in the “plan calculation” section, using what Merced Incentive Compensation calls “calculators”.

Each plan (as is every other object in Merced Incentive Management) is effective dated.  A full audit trail allows to audit the various object versions and revert back to a previous version if required.

My next post will focus on the ‘calculators’ which contain the logic for all calculations performed my Merced Incentive Management.

Tags: , , , , ,

Related Posts:
Merced Systems
ZS Associates